Search:

Type: Posts; User: Papa Moai

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.00 seconds.

  1. I'd love that. Scott and Jean always felt like...

    I'd love that. Scott and Jean always felt like friends first and lovers second. It would be great to see them as amicable exes.
  2. He was hot when he kind of looked like a blue,...

    He was hot when he kind of looked like a blue, slightly hairier Logan. The full-on cat thing is bit too much. And it doesn't help that somewhere along the way he lost his sense of humour.
  3. To be fair, before he turned into a cat-person,...

    To be fair, before he turned into a cat-person, Hank was totally hot. Especially during his Avenger years when he was portrayed as quite the lothario.
  4. Hank is a genius with some geeky pop-culture...

    Hank is a genius with some geeky pop-culture interests. That means he's a nerd the way Tony Stark is a nerd. Beast may have the stereotypical brilliance but Cyclops has the personality of a nerd.
  5. Scott is totally nerdy. Being a socially-inept,...

    Scott is totally nerdy. Being a socially-inept, self-doubting nerd thrust into a position of leadership is the very essense of the character.

    Also I don't see how he does "pretend nice-guy". He's...
  6. I didn't mean to justify his mistakes. Point I...

    I didn't mean to justify his mistakes. Point I was trying to make was that Cyclops could just as easily be a female character. In fact, if I had to swap the gender of an X-Men character, Cyke would...
  7. I'm not sure what you mean by "it's never his...

    I'm not sure what you mean by "it's never his fault". Most Scott-fans I know are honest about his flaws and only object when he's vilified in an overly simplistic, black-and-white manner.

    And I...
  8. Sure, Scott was/is an emotionally-repressed nerd....

    Sure, Scott was/is an emotionally-repressed nerd. But he didn't hold Jean back in any way. She was always perfectly free to be herself. The idea that Jean needs to be the girlfriend of a "cool bad...
  9. True. Scott has a tendency to seek human...

    True. Scott has a tendency to seek human connection and sense of self-worth by offering himself romantically and sexually to basically anyone who happens to show interest at the right time. That is a...
  10. Logan wouldn't make Jean his trophy, but the...

    Logan wouldn't make Jean his trophy, but the writers probably would. Let's face it, Jean was the less interesting one even in a relationship with stuffy old Scott. Pairing her with an exciting...
  11. She's been with the same man her whole life...

    She's been with the same man her whole life because she happened to fall hard for her first boyfriend. That doesn't necessarily mean she wouldn't be open to a more unconventional relationship if it...
  12. They no reason you can't be nice and in a...

    They no reason you can't be nice and in a polyamorous relationship.

    I realize that it seems like about half of Cyclops-fans ship Scott and Logan. But I doubt they would melt. I think that at this...
  13. Both the animated series and the movies made it a...

    Both the animated series and the movies made it a big deal. Just like the antipathy between Wolverine and Cyclops. Two subplots that should have been left in the late 70's, early 80's where they...
  14. Poll: I agree. I always preferred Logan's love...

    I agree. I always preferred Logan's love interests to be from outside the X-Men. But if I'd have to choose one, I'd pick Storm.
  15. Poll: He didn't choose. That was the the tragedy. He...

    He didn't choose. That was the the tragedy. He went to check up on the resurrected Jean, realized he still had feelings for her and spent the early days of X-Factor in a state of numb indecisiveness....
  16. Replies
    317
    Views
    11,800

    That's the thing. Logan is wild and exciting....

    That's the thing. Logan is wild and exciting. Scott is geeky and adorkable. And Jean is... just there.

    The issue isn't who's sexier Logan or Scott or who would make a better boyfriend. The issue...
  17. Replies
    36
    Views
    2,003

    Not her fault really. As I recall it was the...

    Not her fault really. As I recall it was the Avengers who rudely woke her up from her nap. She was just minding her own business, sleeping on the bottom of a lake.
  18. Replies
    317
    Views
    11,800

    Doesn't change my basic argument. Logan's crush...

    Doesn't change my basic argument. Logan's crush on Jean is only interesting because he can't have her. The two of them would make a horribly boring couple.
  19. Poll: I think you might be confusing two different...

    I think you might be confusing two different occations. When Maddie was pregnant, Cyke agreed to go with X-Men to Asgard to save the New Mutants and Storm. I don't think any of them count as Scott's...
  20. Replies
    317
    Views
    11,800

    Problem is that Jean doesn't really have that...

    Problem is that Jean doesn't really have that many love interests. It would be great if she was actually paired up with someone with whom she had an interesting dynamic. Jean/Logan is a pairing build...
  21. Poll: Well, you used the word "imaginery" and I think...

    Well, you used the word "imaginery" and I think that somewhat downplays the seriousness of what happened. An imaginery affair is what I have with Scarlett Johansson. : ) What took place between Scott...
  22. Poll: Absolutely. Even if one could argue that a...

    Absolutely. Even if one could argue that a telepathic affair isn't as bad as a physical one, it's still worse than, say, phone sex. And I think phone sex with a third party is something most people...
  23. Replies
    36
    Views
    2,003

    I don't think any of that excuse Scott's...

    I don't think any of that excuse Scott's behaviour. I like Scott and I'm very forgiving of his flaws and mistakes because I get why he is the way he is. However, he is still responsible for the...
  24. Replies
    38
    Views
    1,544

    This. The overprotective big brother/introverted...

    This. The overprotective big brother/introverted nerd turned reluctant leader aspect is too central to the character. Take that away and much of the essence of the character is lost.

    Edit. Okay,...
  25. Replies
    36
    Views
    2,003

    I think hating Cyclops for his horrible treatment...

    I think hating Cyclops for his horrible treatment of Madelyne is perfectly justified. The Logan-thing, on the other hand, is a pet peeve of mine. Yes, when Logan first joined the team he disliked...
Results 1 to 25 of 141
Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4