Search:

Type: Posts; User: ShaokhaN

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.03 seconds.

  1. Replies
    158
    Views
    6,182

    Thor going full "RRRRrrrrrRRRR" against Malekith...

    Thor going full "RRRRrrrrrRRRR" against Malekith and the Frost Giants was cringeworthy, honestly.
  2. Replies
    42
    Views
    1,506

    Ugh, not Malice again... That persona was...

    Ugh, not Malice again... That persona was interesting when it was first introduced because it helped make Sue into the more assertive Invisible Woman, but I wish writers would stop bringing her up...
  3. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    Of course they knew it. They knew it could be a...

    Of course they knew it. They knew it could be a bluff, they knew that IF there were really bombs he could perhaps be stopped in time, or the bombs could possibly not go off, or even if they did go...
  4. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    I'm not saying that everyone on the destroyed...

    I'm not saying that everyone on the destroyed Earth was indeed ok with it. I was simply pointing out to Majestik that if everyone on that Earth had been thinking like him and me, namely that they'd...
  5. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    I've already addressed this comparison several...

    I've already addressed this comparison several times. The TDK scene had three outs which were absent from the incursion the Illuminati were facing: 1. he's bluffing, 2. someone will stop him in time,...
  6. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    The fact that these people would not have been...

    The fact that these people would not have been aware of what was going on is irrelevant to the point I'm making. Like you and me, if they were given a choice between dying 30 minutes earlier than...
  7. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    Great, I just wanted to make sure that you would...

    Great, I just wanted to make sure that you would not be opposed to living a few minutes less if it led to two universes surviving, which is why the cause of your death was irrelevant as long (as it...
  8. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    That is irrelevant to the question I'm asking......

    That is irrelevant to the question I'm asking... Would you rather see yourself die (from a non-suicide cause) 30 minutes earlier than normal if it could ensure the survival of two universes that...
  9. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    Well, as I see it and as I've been arguing, by...

    Well, as I see it and as I've been arguing, by doing nothing you are choosing not to do anything (consciously), and therefore choosing what results in the deaths of two universes and their...
  10. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    Yes but let's forget Namor. The scenario is a...

    Yes but let's forget Namor. The scenario is a pure construction - I simply want to know if you'd sacrifice 30 minutes of your life if it could ensure the survival of two universes that would...
  11. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    I see. Well, it would not necessarily involve...

    I see. Well, it would not necessarily involve suicide, but instead, let's say, a lightning bolt striking you from the sky. I'm just asking you if you'd rather die 30 minutes early and have two...
  12. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    But imagine that if only you lived thirty minutes...

    But imagine that if only you lived thirty minutes less, everyone else in two universes would be spared. You would only shorten your own life. Would that not be your choice over living 30 minutes more...
  13. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    I don't deny at all that he had a choice with...

    I don't deny at all that he had a choice with regards to which Earth to blow up. But so far you've clearly been arguing for several threads that in your view, when their backs were against the wall...
  14. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    And what about my last question? :) Imagine you...

    And what about my last question? :) Imagine you have to choose between living eight hours more and having two populated universes die with you, or living 7,5 hours more and having two populated...
  15. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    Yes. But you'd still be complaining about the...

    Yes. But you'd still be complaining about the same thing, namely him acting instead of not acting.
  16. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    I agree wholeheartedly. His depiction of Reed, in...

    I agree wholeheartedly. His depiction of Reed, in particular, is extremely frustrating to me.


    Given the extremely slow pace in some of the issues he's been writing for Avengers and NA, I think...
  17. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    But that's the thing, though - those innocent...

    But that's the thing, though - those innocent lives would be lost anyway a few minutes later. And it's not only about saving yourself but about saving two entire universes minus one planet. Even if...
  18. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    No worries, and thanks for the compliment ,-) ...

    No worries, and thanks for the compliment ,-)

    I would consider blowing up a planet to save two universes to be the morally acceptable choice if the only other option was to let two universes...
  19. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    I don't understand your question. English is not...

    I don't understand your question. English is not my first language, so maybe it's a language issue. Again, what do you mean by "cleaner option"? "Cleaner" in what respect?
  20. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    What do you mean, "cleaner option"? Between...

    What do you mean, "cleaner option"?

    Between (1) destroying one world and saving the rest of the two universes, and (2) letting two universes get obliterated, I would undoubtedly choose the first...
  21. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    You are getting it wrong: Namor saved BOTH...

    You are getting it wrong: Namor saved BOTH universes, NOT one. The universe of the destroyed Earth was also saved. The only population which could not be saved was the population of the destroyed...
  22. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    He chose that they should die a few minutes...

    He chose that they should die a few minutes earlier than they would if he hadn't done anything. This is completely different from deciding the death of people who would otherwise survive. And you...
  23. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    The fact that there was an unopposed incursion...

    The fact that there was an unopposed incursion happening meant that the entire populations of two universes would have been erased if Namor hadn't done anything. Why do you fail to understand this?...
  24. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    As I clearly explained before...

    As I clearly explained before, the inhabitants of the GS Earth (and probably most, if not all of these other Earths he's faced with the Cabal) would have died anyway, a few minutes later. He...
  25. Replies
    1,529
    Views
    44,657

    Namor doesn't choose who dies. I can't believe...

    Namor doesn't choose who dies. I can't believe you're misrepresenting this AGAIN. The only choice is whether most live or nobody lives. See here. The inhabitants of the other Earths would die anyway...
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4