Page 1 of 17 1234511 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 246
  1. #1
    Mighty Member Thor2014's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Asgard
    Posts
    1,582

    Default Justice Society Elimination Game #1

    (Edit: My previous attempt was too unwieldy so I'm gonna try again with about twenty names.)

    The rules are the same as usual..

    - You can post once every 5 turns (there must be AT LEAST 4 posts between your votes).
    OR after two hours have passed with no other action.
    - Copy the list from the most recent post. Remember to delete the previous poster's +/-. And be certain to edit your own post quickly if someone else has posted between the time you copied the list and posted your turn.
    - On one turn you may both add one to a title's score and subtract one from a title.
    - at 20 titles remaining, the above rule will be amended and you'll only be allowed to do one or the other.
    - You MUST indicate your action with a + or - sign. It'd be nice if you bolded the name too.
    - There is a 20 point cap per title.
    - When a title has no points left, he/she is eliminated
    - If a mistake occurs, call PAUSE and nobody else post until the list is rectified

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 10
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 10
    Earth-Two Robin 10
    Earth-Two Huntress 10
    Miss America 10
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 10
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 10
    Damage 10
    Starman-Thom Kallor 10
    Earth-22 Superman 10
    Judomaster 10
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10

  2. #2
    Mighty Member Thor2014's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Asgard
    Posts
    1,582

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 10
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 11 (+1)
    Earth-Two Robin 10
    Earth-Two Huntress 10
    Miss America 9 (-1)
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 10
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 10
    Damage 10
    Starman-Thom Kallor 10
    Earth-22 Superman 10
    Judomaster 10
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10

  3. #3
    Ultimate Member Assam's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Posts
    11,146

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 10
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11 (+1)
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 11
    Earth-Two Robin 10
    Earth-Two Huntress 10
    Miss America 9
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 10
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 10
    Damage 10
    Starman-Thom Kallor 10
    Earth-22 Superman 10
    Judomaster 9 (-1)
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10
    Current Top 20 Titles: New Super-Man and the Justice League of China/Runaways/Mighty Morphin Power Rangers/Go Go Power Rangers/Maxwell's Demons/Exit Stage Left: The Snagglepuss Chronicles/Paper Girls/Unbeatable Squirrel Girl/Quantum and Woody/Detective Comics/Exiles/Fence/X-Men Red/Ms. Marvel/Domino/Mech Cadet Yu/The Flash/Champions/The Wildstorm: Michael Cray/New Mutants: Dead Souls

  4. #4
    Astonishing Member
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    2,751

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 10
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 11
    Earth-Two Robin 10
    Earth-Two Huntress 11 (+1)
    Miss America 9
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 10
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 10
    Damage 10
    Starman-Thom Kallor 10
    Earth-22 Superman 9 (-1)
    Judomaster 9
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10

  5. #5
    Astonishing Member dan12456's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2015
    Posts
    2,471

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 10
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 12 (+1)
    Earth-Two Robin 10
    Earth-Two Huntress 11
    Miss America 9
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 10
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 10
    Damage 10
    Starman-Thom Kallor 10
    Earth-22 Superman 8 (-1)
    Judomaster 9
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10
    Current Pull: The Beauty, Lazarus, The Realm, Seven to Eternity, Aquaman, Flash, Green Lanterns, The Immortal Men, Mera: Queen of Atlantis, Sideways Daredevil, Black Panther.

    Future pull: Justice League Odyssey, Captain America (Coates), Thor, Death of the Inhumans.

  6. #6
    Superman of E-6 Thor-Ul's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Astounding World of Argon.
    Posts
    2,382

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 10
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 12
    Earth-Two Robin 10
    Earth-Two Huntress 11
    Miss America 9
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 10
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 10
    Damage 11 (+1)
    Starman-Thom Kallor 9 (-1)
    Earth-22 Superman 8
    Judomaster 9
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10
    Internet Rule 14: Do not argue with trolls it means they win.

  7. #7
    Incredible Member billee0918's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    658

    Default

    Default
    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 10
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 12 (+1)
    Earth-Two Robin 10
    Earth-Two Huntress 11
    Miss America 9
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 10
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 11 (+1)
    Damage 10
    Starman-Thom Kallor 10
    Earth-22 Superman 7 (-1)
    Judomaster 9
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10

  8. #8
    Incredible Member Kaijudo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2014
    Posts
    697

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 10
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 12
    Earth-Two Robin 10
    Earth-Two Huntress 11
    Miss America 9
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 11 (+1)
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 11
    Damage 10
    Starman-Thom Kallor 9 (-1)
    Earth-22 Superman 7
    Judomaster 9
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10

  9. #9
    Incredible Member Harpoon's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    564

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 11 (+1)
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 12
    Earth-Two Robin 10
    Earth-Two Huntress 11
    Miss America 9
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 11
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 11
    Damage 10
    Starman-Thom Kallor 9
    Earth-22 Superman 6 (-1)
    Judomaster 9
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10

  10. #10
    Mighty Member
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    1,452

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 11
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 12
    Earth-Two Robin 10
    Earth-Two Huntress 11
    Miss America 9
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 11
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 12 (+1)
    Damage 10
    Starman-Thom Kallor 9
    Earth-22 Superman 5 (-1)
    Judomaster 9
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10

  11. #11
    Astonishing Member BatmanJones's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Posts
    2,448

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 11
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 12
    Earth-Two Robin 11 (+1)
    Earth-Two Huntress 11
    Miss America 9
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 11
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 12
    Damage 10
    Starman-Thom Kallor 9
    Earth-22 Superman 5
    Judomaster 8 (-1)
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10

  12. #12
    Mighty Member
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    1,452

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 11
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 12
    Earth-Two Robin 11
    Earth-Two Huntress 11
    Miss America 9
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 11
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 13 (+1)
    Damage 10
    Starman-Thom Kallor 9
    Earth-22 Superman 4 (-1)
    Judomaster 8
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10

  13. #13
    Ultimate Member Assam's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2017
    Posts
    11,146

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 11
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 12
    Earth-Two Robin 11
    Earth-Two Huntress 11
    Miss America 8 (-1)
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 11
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 13
    Damage 11 (+1)
    Starman-Thom Kallor 9
    Earth-22 Superman 4
    Judomaster 8
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10

    Am I the only one who really liked what was done with Earth-22 Superman in JSA?
    Current Top 20 Titles: New Super-Man and the Justice League of China/Runaways/Mighty Morphin Power Rangers/Go Go Power Rangers/Maxwell's Demons/Exit Stage Left: The Snagglepuss Chronicles/Paper Girls/Unbeatable Squirrel Girl/Quantum and Woody/Detective Comics/Exiles/Fence/X-Men Red/Ms. Marvel/Domino/Mech Cadet Yu/The Flash/Champions/The Wildstorm: Michael Cray/New Mutants: Dead Souls

  14. #14
    Fantastic Member Graphic Autist's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2017
    Posts
    393

    Default

    Powergirl!

  15. #15
    Mighty Member
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Posts
    1,452

    Default

    Flash-Jay Garrick 10
    Green Lantern-Alan Scott 10
    Sandman-Wesley Dodds 11
    Hawkman 10
    Doctor Mid-Nite-Charles McNider 10
    Starman-Ted Knight 10
    Golden Age Wonder Woman 10
    Wildcat-Ted Grant 11
    Black Canary-Dinah Drake 12
    Earth-Two Robin 11
    Earth-Two Huntress 11
    Miss America 8
    Hawkgirl-Shiera Sanders 10
    Hawkgirl-Kendra Saunders 10
    Black Canary-Dinah Lance 10
    Hourman-Rick Tyler 11
    Liberty Belle/Jesse Quick 14 (+1)
    Damage 11
    Starman-Thom Kallor 8 (-1)
    Earth-22 Superman 4
    Judomaster 8
    Liberty Belle-Libby Lawrence 10

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •